Daniel Craig`s `Defiance` character: source of controversial debate

Daniel Craig crouches with his back pressed hard against the white trunk of a birch tree. Gripping an Erma MP40 submachine gun, he glares over his shoulder at a target in the forest.

This is not a new James Bond film, but Craig playing the lead role as Tuvia Bielski, a real life Jewish partisan commander who waged guerrilla warfare against the Germans in Poland during the Second World War - reports Times Online.

Bielski’s and his fighters saved more than 1,200 civilians, mainly Jews, and their exploits are about to be celebrated in “Defiance”, a $50 million Hollywood film which premieres this week.

Bielski’s extraordinary courage is meant to cast a new light on the Holocaust. After the Nazis murdered Bielski's parents and his first wife, that he and his brothers Zus, Asael and Aharon decided to fight back rather than accept their fate. The brothers transform fellow Jews from the terrorised, hopeless victims -- familiar in films such as Schinder’s List and The Pianist -- into ruthless fighters capable of taking on and beating the Nazis.

But in Poland, the film has raised some uncomfortable questions about Bielski’s behaviour in his area of operations around Nowogrodek between 1943 and 1945. Some Poles fear that in telling Bielski’s story the Hollywood has airbrushed out some unpleasant episodes from the story.

Historians say Bielski was affiliated with Soviet partisans directed by the feared NKVD, a forerunner of the KGB. He even named his unit ’Kalinin’, after Stalin’s crony Mikhail Ivanovich Kalinin. Towards the end of the War, Soviet partisans terrorised ethnic Poles in Eastern Poland, including the region where Bielski’s Kalinin unit operated. Some Poles suspect that Bielski’s partisans were not only intent on driving the Germans out but opening the way for Poland to come under Soviet control.

The most serious allegations concerns the events of 8 May 1943 when some 128 unarmed Polish gentiles were slaughtered at Naliboki in the province Nowogrodek. Evidence suggests Soviet partisans were responsible, but there is confusion about specifically which unit undertook the killings - and Bielski’s group has not been ruled out.

Poland’s Institute of National Remembrance (IPN) is investigating the Naliboki case and the culpability of the Bielski partisans has been identified as one possibility. Though the IPN has drawn fire for alleged bias, its investigation of the 1941 Jedwabne pogrom concluded that Poles rather than Germans were at fault, which led to an official apology from Poland in 2001.

The Polish newspaper Gazeta Wyborcza, edited by Adam Michnik, who describes himself as a Pole of Jewish descent, has led the Bielski debate. The daily has claimed the Bielskis tended not to engage in combat with Germans as depicted in the film, but rather spent its energy stealing civilian supplies in order survive.

Ed Zwick, the director of Defiance, has admitted his film, based on a historical account by Nechama Tec, is not a simple fight between good and evil.

“The Bielskis weren’t saints,” Zwick said in a statement. “They were flawed heroes, which is what makes them so real and so fascinating. They faced any number of difficult moral dilemmas that the movie seeks to dramatise: Does one have to become a monster to fight monsters? Does one have to sacrifice his humanity to save humanity?”

But Poles are now taking these questions a step further: was Tuvia Bielski and his Jewish partisans involved in the 128 deaths at Naliboki? Was he a Polish Jewish hero or was he a Polish traitor doing Stalin’s dirty work? Or was he both? And is it anti-Semitic for Poles to even ask these questions?


“I believe it’s just a consistent Polish anti-Semitism and the Poles are sloughing [palming] off their own crimes of being an enemy of the Jews during World War II,” said Robert Bielski, Tuvia’s son, in Jewish newspaper The Forward. “The 128 people are in no way close to the millions of people that the Polish people herded towards the Germans so they could be extinguished.” He insisted that the Bielskis were not in Naliboki at the time of the massacre.

The subject of anti-Semitism is fraught with complexity in Poland. Some commentators claim Polish gentiles were complicit in the Holocaust. Around 37 Jews were killed by Polish gentiles in the 1946 Kielce pogrom, and over 20,000 Polish Jews were forced by the Soviet-backed regime to emigrate in 1968.

But many Poles argue they are not a generally anti-Semitic nation. No Polish organizations collaborated with the Nazis and more Poles are honoured at Israel’s Yad Vashem than any other nation. The Polish Home Army, the largest resistance movement in Europe, saved thousands of Jews through organizations like Zegota, the ’Polish Council to Aid Jews’. Over 2.3 million Polish gentiles were killed by the Nazis, many as a penalty for saving Jewish people.

The last living Bielski brother, Aharon Bielski, who changed his name to Aron Bell when he emigrated to the US in 1951, was arrested in Florida last year on suspicion of swindling around $250,000 in life savings from his Polish Catholic neighbour Janina Zaniewska, who herself survived Nazi imprisonment during the war.

Several members of the Bielski family served in the Israeli armed forces, including Zus Bielski’s grandson Elan, who recently joined up to the Israeli Defence Force.

Discuss this news here...